Dispute declared over new Council policies

The Council are making to long standing agreements, policies and procedures that affect you at work. We are so concerned by these changes that we advised the Council on the 25 November 2025 that we are in formal dispute and the introduction of the policies on the 1 December 2025 should not take place.

The trade unions have worked with HR colleagues in what is called a Policy Working Group for many years.  Although most policies have not changed very much over that period, we worked together on trying to improve policy, amend policy to keep up with changes in the law as well as to introduce new policy where appropriate.

Since the issuing of the Section 114 Notice and the introduction of spending controls, new HR Interims have been attending the group suggesting huge policy changes.  They have rewritten both the Grievance and Disciplinary policy both of which are much more complicated, less transparent, and less fair than the originals.  We have opposed these changes, but they have been imposed by the Council.

The way the group works has been changed.  In the past the Council would provide a copy of the policy they wanted to change with track changes marking what they were proposing, and we would work through the suggested changes together.  Now HR present a new policy, often merging lots of current policies together that they do not supply, they do not provide track changes or a proper explanation of why the change is necessary or sensible.  We also feel that they don’t provide adequate time to consult on what are in effect big changes that have real impacts.

What has been most frustrating is their attempt to dress up the changes they are making as improvements when in reality they are making policies worse for employees and then trying to cover it up hoping most staff won’t notice.

We have made the point at every forum we sit in that the financial problems of the Council were not created by the staff and that staff should not be made to pay for them by a worsening set of terms and conditions at work.

As you know the Oracle programme tender was agreed at the cost of £19M and the final cost is now known to be closer to £190M.  UNISON representatives working in both IT and finance warned the Council early on and throughout the introduction and implementation that things were going badly with the programme but were ignored by the senior leadership at the time.  That senior leadership are no longer here and as far as we know have not been held at all accountable for the complete mess that they left the Council in. UNISON have made it clear from the start that it was the handling of the Oracle programme that led to the council being declared bankrupt and trying to blame the unions and equal pay was a smokescreen to cover their incompetence.

UNISON will continue to challenge the unfair aspects of the changes being imposed.

Absence and Leave policy.
The council has announced significant changes to the Absence and Leave Policy. While there are some improvements, many changes reduce benefits and flexibility that staff have relied on for years.  We attended consultation meetings with the Council and made clear our opposition to various parts of the policy, we asked for an Equality Impact Assessment to be carried out, but one has yet to be provided even though they have imposed the changes from the 1st December.  At first the Council said we had agreed the changes however, once challenged, they did admit to staff that they consulted the trade unions which is different to the trade unions agreeing.

Key Changes:

  • Cancellation of Booked Leave: Managers can now require you to cancel pre-booked leave for “business needs” giving double the amount of notice as leave booked.  They say when questioned, that this will be in an emergency only.  If this was the case, it should clearly state that in the policy, but it doesn’t.
  • Refusal to Cancel Leave: If you change your mind about booked leave, managers can refuse your request to cancel it without giving a reason.
  • Removal of Extra Leave Purchase: The option to buy additional leave has been removed. Many members tell us that they really appreciated this option being available as it allowed extended visits to relatives overseas, managing long term illness and helped with managing childcare during school holidays.
  • Anniversary based Leave: The trade unions agreed to the introduction of anniversary based leave due to the problems encountered by services being short of staff in March due to the number of staff not managing to take their leave and trying to fit it in by the end of the year.  This has worked really well however, but the new Oracle system can’t handle it so it is being removed.  Anniversary based leave is also written into our contracts of employment via the Birmingham Workforce Contract and so cannot be removed unilaterally in this way.

Why This Is Worse Overall:

  • The previous policy provided greater flexibility for staff.
  • These changes reduce your ability to balance work with personal responsibilities.
  • They give managers more control over your leave, reducing certainty for staff planning time off.

UNISON believes these changes are detrimental to staff welfare and work-life balance.

We are concerned about the wording of the clauses on special leave as they are unclear.  We have had lots of contact from members concerned that their ability to take special leave is being affected due to the addition of a cumulative total.

We have asked HR to make sure that their FAQ’s are made clearer as this is not the case.  In fact, staff can now take up to 20% of their annual working hours as paid special leave if they fall into any of the special leave categories.  For example, if you are a full time 36.5 hours worker over the 12 months, leave period you could have up to days 52 paid special leave (20% of 36.5 weekly hours X 52 weeks) if more than one of the special leave categories applied to you.  This is an improvement on the ability to take special leave for certain proscribed circumstances however, it does cut the ability to take compassionate special leave from 10 to 5 days.

Recruitment and Selection policy
Again, many changes have been made to this policy. We attended consultation meetings with the Council and made clear our opposition to various parts of the policy, we asked for an Equality Impact Assessment to be carried out, but one has yet to be provided even though they plan to impose the changes from the 1st December.

Key Changes:

The removal of the Recruitment & Selection Complaints Procedure:  This 8-page procedure laid out the rules of how to complain if you felt you were treated unfairly in the recruitment process.  It allowed for the recruitment process to be halted while the matter is investigated and provided for remedies. The Grievance Procedure is not an adequate replacement.

No union consultation on changes to job description: Previously the Council has negotiated changes to job description with the relevant unions.

CV’s

Appointing Agency, Interims and Consultants to permanent roles without competitive interview: This is unacceptable, and the Council has been told this on several occasions. This will disadvantage permanent employees who may not have applied for posts due to their temporary nature. All posts should be subject to competitive interview (with the exception of departmental restructures).

Why This Is Worse Overall:

  • Complaints about recruitment must be dealt with using a weakened Grievance Process rather than a clear policy with timelines that ensured the process was halted while the complaint was investigated.
  • The section on applications, longlisting, and shortlisting are poorly worded and confusing.

General Policy Change 
The policy working group is now looking at the Capability policy and procedure and we will keep you updated on progress.  As well as the polices that affect staff we are also currently challenging the changes they want to impose on trade union consultation.  There is an attempt to weaken our power to challenge them on your behalf by changing how consultation with the unions takes place.  There is even a proposal to remove the elected Cabinet member that chairs the Corporate Consultive Committee which would seriously weaken democratic accountability in the consultation process.

No one seems to be able to explain why the Council would want to redesign every policy and procedure while trying to complete a full and thorough job evaluation process to end the councils equal pay liability, manage huge cuts in funding resulting in redundancies and settling a huge number of equal pay settlements. As your elected representatives we have certainly never been involved in so many important large projects all at once.

We have lodged a formal dispute about the new policies and will keep you updated as these progress.

If you are in a team or workplace that doesn’t currently have a UNISON workplace rep/steward but would like to consider getting one do get in touch.  Stewards vote on union policy on everything from BCC policy to what our pay claim should be at regular meetings and your team miss out if you are not part of that.  Time off is given for attendance at meetings so do get in touch.

Best wishes

Caroline Johnson

Tracey Mooney

Joint Branch Secretaries

UNISON Birmingham